|
|
"Any Thing But a 'Pacific Mail' "
Matron Columbia. "Children, you must stop putting those dangerous irons in the fire; somebody is sure to have his fingers burned."
This Harper’s Weekly cartoon by Thomas Nast criticizes federal
government subsidies to the Pacific Mail Steamship Company and other businesses.
In December 1874, the House Ways and Means Committee initiated an
investigation of the possible bribery of government officials by the Pacific
Mail Steamship Company during the firm’s quest to secure a federal subsidy.
The House bookkeeper testified that 60 congressmen had each deposited a
thousand-dollar bill in their accounts concurrent with the passage of the
Pacific Mail subsidy. House investigators were not anxious to indict their
fellow members (or perhaps themselves in some cases), so the bookkeeper was not
asked to divulge the names of the depositors.
The hearings, in fact, produced a pattern of witnesses admitting that large
amounts of money had changed hands, while disavowing that such acts constituted
bribery, and the committee continuing its disinterest in identifying the
congressional beneficiaries of the payoffs. One witness, for example, confessed
to accepting $56,000 (more than the president’s salary) from Pacific Mail to
persuade a senatorial friend to vote for the subsidy, but the witness denied
that the payment was a bride. The investigation also revealed that Pacific Mail
had paid a reporter and an editor of the Washington Chronicle to print
favorable news stories and editorials about the company. With overwhelming
evidence against Pacific Mail, the House voted on January 25, 1875, to repeal
the company’s subsidy, and the Senate followed suit on February 23. No
congressmen were indicted.
Nast’s setting for this cartoon might have been inspired by an editorial in
the January 9, 1875, issue of Harper’s Weekly. In comparing the
activities of Pacific Mail to risky stock investments, editor George William
Curtis wrote: "It is often said that if people choose to burn their fingers
in stock gambling, it is their own affair and pity for them is wasted. But the
consequences of very little misconduct can be strictly confined to the
evil-doer." Curtis pointed out that one of Pacific Mail’s steamers burned
at sea with loss of life at the same time that the company was profligately
dispensing its money among various members of Congress.
In this cartoon, Nast portrays Pacific Mail as a bad boy who has burned his
fingers on the red-hot iron "subsidies." Other businesses appear as
boys who eagerly anticipate grabbing other subsidy irons from the U.S. Treasury
fireplace. One boy even tries to cool an iron’s heat by blowing on it.
Columbia, the matron of the U.S. Almshouse (Congress), chastises the boys for
their behavior. In the left-background, Uncle Sam wipes his brow, beaded with
sweat from the heat and anxiety, as small boys/businesses begin their reliance
on government funding by feeding on pap (soft baby food). Behind Columbia,
stands the boy Credit Mobilier, representing the holding company for the Union
Pacific Railroad Company, which created a major scandal in 1873 by bribing
congressmen to gain federal subsidies. Credit Mobilier snickers to see that
Pacific Mail has suffered the same fate that put his arm in a bandage.
Robert C. Kennedy
|
|
|
